
Located in George Town, Grand Cayman the present Elmslie Memorial Church was constructed during the 1920’s by Captain Rayal Bodden who being a naval architect designed the roof to resemble a ship’s hull turned upside down. The Presbyterian community however actually dates back to 1845 when the Presbyterian Church of Jamaica sent forth a ship of Missionaries intended to preach the Gospel in Africa, but instead ended up wrecked on the Cayman Islands reef. Discovering the islands had no organized church, Reverend Hope Waddell who led the Missionaries appealed to ministerial officials to establish a presence on the Caymans. The following year Reverend James Elmslie volunteered to go when it seemed no other would building the church in George Town upon the site of the former Anglican Church that was destroyed by a hurricane in 1838 and spent almost twenty years traveling the islands spreading his faith until returning to Scotland in 1863.
This church was built by Captain Rayal Brazley Bodden (1885-1976), my wife’ great-uncle
https://sites.google.com/site/oharaberkeleygenealogy/d/m/gu
Captain Roland Bodden II was Rayal’s brother and he is responsible for the finish carpentry of the beautiful ceiling of the church
http://www.ieyenews.com/wordpress/one-of-rev-elmslies-descendants-comes-to-cayman-islands-for-a-visit/
The island’s history features many of my wife’s family members and with so many shared surnames and similar given names, it can be confusing at times!
Thanks for the correction Sean, and it looks like the Elmslie Memorial Church website has updated their information as well. Apologies that we had the wrong name initially, but given what you said about this family having such deep roots in the island, certainly unsurprising that there could be such confusion. Thanks again!